Indian Institute of Technology Earthquake Research Provides
Benchmark for STAAD.Pro Analysis Accuracy
The
Indian Institute of Technology in Rorkee, India, which is
studying the affects of earthquakes on multi-story buildings,
has released research findings that used data gathered from
last year's devastating Gujarat earthquake in western India
to benchmark the results modeled by STAAD.Pro structural analysis
and design software. The research carried out by IIT verified
and confirmed the accuracy of STAAD.Pro's advanced dynamic
analysis of structures modeled to determine the affects of
earthquakes. The highly regarded academic institution, equivalent
to Massachusetts Institute of Technology and California Institute
of Technology in the U.S., is conducting ongoing research
through its Department of Earthquake Engineering, which places
earthquake sensors in a number of buildings throughout India
to record data. IIT's instrumentation recorded a significant
amount of data from January 26, 1002 Gujarat earthquake that
measured 6.9 in the Richter scale. "The data gathered
by researchers and used as a benchmark to compare results
obtained by STAAD.Pro's structural analysis contributes to
a growing body of knowledge about how to design and build
safer buildings able to withstand earthquakes," said
Santanu Das, Vice President, Technology Strategy for netGuru,
Inc. (NASDAQ: NGRU). Research Engineers International, a division
of netGuru, Inc., is the developer of STAAD.Pro structural
analysis and design software.
Among
the structures in which IIT researchers placed sensors was
a 10-story residential building which served as staff quarters
of the Regional Passport Office Building in Ahmedabad, state
capital and closest major city to the epicenter of the Gujarat
earthquake. The instrumentation, comprising 14 force balance
accelerometers placed throughout the building, recorded data
form main shock and one aftershock. Tri-axial and uniaxial
sensors were installed on the ground floor, top floor and
near the beam-column joint below the slab of each floor. Fourteen
acceleration time histories of 133.53 seconds duration at
200 samples per second were recorded by these locations. According
to the IIT, this is the first time in India that an instrumented
building has yielded such data during an earthquake. Using
STAAD.Pro, IIT researchers created a 3-D space frame model
of the steel and concrete building using available structural
drawings. The mathematical model included plan, elevation
and isometric views of the structure. The space frame model
comprised 799 nodes out of which 67 nodes were fixed nodes
at the base, 1.572 beam elements and 219 plane stress slab
elements. The researchers made a number of assumptions in
the mathematical model, taking into account stiffness and
mass of walls, various stress elements, thickness of truss
elements, dead loads, live loads and elastic behavior of the
building among other variables.
For seismic engineers, an earthquake is an event that gives
them the opportunity to learn more about the seismic response
of man-made structures, with the objective to record their
seismic response, is one of the most effective ways of determining
the feedback on performance of structures during an earthquake.
As some very critical data on different floors of the building
was recorded during the main shock and first aftershock of
the Gujarat earthquake, it provided researchers with an opportunity
to compare the results of STAAD.Pro's analytical tools with
the recorded response of the building. With the recorded data
as a benchmark, a dynamic analysis was performed to compare
the recorded data with results obtained by using the software
to analyze the building's vibrational characteristics as well
as response at different locations of the structure. The IIT
comparison of the recorded data and the results of the STAAD.Pro
analysis of the model yielded similar responses, according
to the recently released research study. While IIT researchers
concluded that the analytical results of the STAAD.Pro model
generally matched well with the measured data of the building,
they cautioned that more research is needed to adequately
arrive at useful conclusions that may benefit the design and
construction industry. "We are certainly pleased with
the finding of IIT's study," Das commented. "The
research has resulted in a number of improvements to STAAD.Pro
2002. These refinements are part of our ongoing effort to
provide the most useful and accurate structural analysis and
design software tools for engineers."
Funding
for IIT's ongoing earthquake research project is provided
from the World Bank through the Government of India's Department
of Science and Technology, which has supported the research
of IIT over the past 25 years.
The earthquake that shook the Indian state of Gujarat on the
morning of January 26, 2001, India's Republic Day, was one
of the two most deadly earthquakes to strike the country in
its recorded history. The official Government of India figures
placed the death toll at approximately 20.000 and the number
of injured at 166.000. Indications are that 600.000 people
were left homeless, with 348.000 houses destroyed and an additional
844.000 damaged. The Indian State Department estimated that
the earthquake affected, directly or directly, 15.0 million
people out of a total population of 37.8 million in the state
of Gujarat. Some estimates placed direct economic losses at
$1.3 billion, with other estimates indicating losses as high
as $5 billion.
Bauingenieur
- Die richtungsweisende Zeitschrift im Bauingenieurwesen (Juli/August
2003)
|